Cookware Set vs Building it Piece by Piece: Which is Better Value?

If you're setting up a kitchen, a cookware set can look like the obvious value. But is it actually cheaper than choosing each piece individually?

The answer depends on what you already own, what you’ll use and, most importantly, what the individual pieces actually cost. Rather than assuming a cookware set is always the smarter buy, put the two receipts side by side.

Here’s when buying a set makes sense, when building your collection piece by piece is better, and how Baccarat’s pricing changes the equation.

What is the Best Home Cookware Set Cost Compared with Buying Each Piece?

A six-piece stainless steel cookware set, like Baccarat's iD3 range, typically costs about the same at RRP as buying the same six pieces individually. Sets are often marketed as the smart move by default, and sometimes they are, but a set is also just multiple pieces in one box, and the only real question is whether that box is doing you any favours on price.

Here's roughly what each piece costs bought on its own:

Add it up, and you land in roughly the same territory as buying the six-piece set outright, which typically sits around $1,100 to $1,150 at RRP. Whichever way comes out cheaper or more expensive on any given day usually comes down to which individual pieces happen to be discounted at the time.

The biggest advantage of a set is convenience and consistency. So, if you’re starting a kitchen from scratch and think you’d use all six pieces, the set gives you everything in one purchase. If you already own several of these pieces, buying only what’s missing may be the better option. Baccarat also offers 4-piece and 10-piece cookware sets for those after a smaller or more extensive range.

Plus, there’s currently free standard shipping* on orders over $130, whereas for purchases under $130 standard shipping is around $12. You do the maths! Baccarat often runs discounts on various products across the site, so the RRP could be lower at any point.

*Prices shown reflect approximate current ranges and are subject to change.

The Best Cookware Set: A Set Vs Buying Piece by Piece

A cookware set usually takes the cake when you need most of the pieces in it. Buying individually makes more sense when you only need one or two.

CHOICE recommends considering whether you'll actually use every piece in a cookware set before buying. Choose the cookware you buy based on how you cook and stop overcomplicating your kitchen!

What Should You Look for in a Recommended Cookware Set?

Before buying, check the pieces that are included: the sizes, the materials, and whether they suit your everyday cooking. There’s no benefit in paying for a specialist pan that spends most of its life at the back of the cupboard.

A recommended cookware set is one where the pieces are genuinely useful together. A set that covers your most common cooking jobs is likely to provide better value than a larger set with several pieces you rarely need.

The Baccarat iD3 example illustrates this point. Rather than judging the set by the number of pieces in the box, look at what each pan would do in your kitchen. If you would buy several of those pieces anyway, the set becomes much easier to justify. If you only want one particular pan, buying that piece on its own keeps your spending focused.

For smaller kitchens, this matters even more. A compact collection of cookware you use constantly is more useful than a cupboard packed with pans chosen simply because they were included in a deal.

So what kitchen cookware scenario suits your situation? If you are starting your cookware collection from scratch or replacing most of a mismatched or worn-out collection, buying a full set is recommended. If you’re only missing one or two pieces or want to mix materials or ranges on purpose, consider buying individual pieces. 

Why the Guarantee Changes the Real Cost, Not Just the Set Price

If you’re dropping a decent chunk of money to invest in cookware, the plan probably isn’t to replace it again next year. That means the purchase goes beyond what leaves your bank account that day. You’re also looking at the quality you’re getting for that money, how the cookware performs over time, how often you actually use it and, most importantly, what kind of guarantee sits behind the purchase.

A general ‘lifetime guarantee’ sounds pretty good in the grand scheme of things, but the word itself doesn’t give you a particularly useful number. Baccarat’s Lifetime Guarantee does: 25 years from the date of purchase for eligible products, subject to the guarantee terms and conditions. That gives you a solid period of cover you can factor into the bigger picture when you’re comparing the upfront cost of a cookware set or individual pieces.

We’re not going to sit here and pretend that means you can divide the price by 25 and call it your annual cookware cost. That’s not how guarantees work, and your saucepan won’t suddenly conk out on you the moment the guarantee period ends. It simply means there’s a defined period in which Baccarat stands behind eligible products.

The same long-term thinking applies when buying individual pieces. A lower price can look tempting, but it isn’t necessarily better value if you end up replacing it sooner. Look at the price, what the cookware is made for, how often you’ll use it and the protection that comes with it.

Brands and Their Guarantees

Baccarat: Lifetime Guarantee with 25 years defined length from purchase.

Le Creuset: Lifetime Guarantee claim, but not stated in years.

HexClad:  Lifetime Guarantee claim, but not stated in years.

GreenPan: Warranty stated as 2 years.

Which Piece Should You Buy First if You’re Building the Kitchen Piece by Piece?

If you’re building a cookware collection gradually, start with the pieces you’ll use most often, then add specialty cookware as your cooking needs grow.

1. Frypan first: A frypan is one of the workhorses of the kitchen. A 24 to 26cm frypan is a practical starting point for everyday cooking, whether you’re frying meat, cooking vegetables or making a quick one-pan meal.

2. Saucepan second: An 18 to 20cm saucepan covers plenty of everyday jobs, including sauces, grains and vegetables. It’s a smaller piece, but one you’re likely to reach for regularly. Baccarat also offers a range of other pots and pans that will help you build a cookware collection customised to the way you cook.

3. Casserole or stockpot third: Once you’re cooking bigger batches, braises, soups or stock, a casserole or stockpot becomes more useful. This is the point where buying a larger piece can be justified by what you actually cook.

4. Specialty pieces last: Woks, grill pans and steamers can be useful additions, but they don’t need to be day-one purchases. Add them once you know you’ll use them often.

The advantage of building piece by piece is simple: your collection grows with your cooking habits rather than filling your cupboards with cookware you rarely reach for.

The Baccarat Bottom Line

The better-value option isn’t decided by whether cookware comes in a box. It comes down to the numbers, what you need and what you’ll use.

What to look for in a cookware set? If you’re starting from scratch or replacing most of your cookware, compare the current price of a matched set with the individual pieces you would otherwise buy. If you already have the essentials, buying one or two pieces individually may be the smarter move. In other words, put the two receipts side by side. Let the numbers, not the box size, make the decision.

Explore Baccarat’s cookware sets, or build your collection with individual frypans, saucepans and stockpots.

Frequently Asked Questions: Baccarat Cookware Set

1. Is it cheaper to buy a cookware set or the same pieces individually?

A cookware set can be cheaper when you need most of the pieces included, but individual and set prices can vary. Compare the current prices of the pieces you actually need before buying.

2. What pieces come in Baccarat’s cookware sets?

The pieces vary by range and set size. Baccarat offers cookware sets in different configurations, including sets containing frypans, saucepans, casseroles, sauté pans and steamers.

3. Can I mix individual pieces in with a set?

Yes. You can add individual cookware to a set as your needs change, including choosing a different material or range for a particular cooking job.

4. How long does Baccarat’s Lifetime Guarantee last?

Baccarat’s Lifetime Guarantee covers eligible products for 25 years from the date of purchase, subject to the guarantee terms and conditions.

5. What size cookware set suits a small kitchen?

A smaller cookware set can be a practical starting point for a small kitchen because it includes the essentials without taking up as much cupboard space. If you already own some cookware, buying individual pieces may be even more space-efficient.

Related Articles